RFC pads
(request for comment)
< DRAFT+ >
Pads that need your feedback & how to give it.
Last updated:
20201009 user testing merge
Table of Contents
1 | How to help? |
2 | Site goals |
3 | Read (Updated 2020/10) |
3.1 | →RFC++ |
3.2 | →RFC+ (12) |
3.3 | →RFC (37) |
4 | *** Giving useful feedback |
4.1 | A) QUICK |
4.2 | B) DETAILED |
4.2.1 | * Start a reader pad, with the name "reader-yourinitials |
4.2.2 | * While reading, note down |
4.2.3 | * Give some general feedback |
4.3 | C) THOROUGH |
4.3.1 | C1) MARK ON DOCUMENT |
4.3.2 | C2) WITH HYPOTHES.IS TOOL |
¶How to help?
Pads on totalism.org are collectively authored and reviewed. If they made it to "RFC" editor mark, they are sort of released, but need more feedback.
Please read them, give comments, and help improve the quality of the site.
You can find more details about how to do that below, OR, simply just email your thoughts → info@totalism.org .
Pads on totalism.org are collectively authored and reviewed. If they made it to "RFC" editor mark, they are sort of released, but need more feedback.
Please read them, give comments, and help improve the quality of the site.
You can find more details about how to do that below, OR, simply just email your thoughts → info@totalism.org .
¶Site goals
* Be a real resource to people with affinity & similar goals
* Reference & point to quality external sources
* Look clear & minimalistic
* Encourage connecting and working together
* Encourage real-world action
* [...]
* Be a real resource to people with affinity & similar goals
* Reference & point to quality external sources
* Look clear & minimalistic
* Encourage connecting and working together
* Encourage real-world action
* [...]
¶ →RFC+ (12)
🔗hacking-housing-pad
🔗idiots-guide
🔗noise-temples
🔗puzzles
🔗roles
🔗vaults
🔗why-how-what
🔗season7-B
🔗postmarket
🔗postmarket-trail
🔗laptop
🔗trucko
🔗metrics
🔗hacking-housing-pad
🔗idiots-guide
🔗noise-temples
🔗puzzles
🔗roles
🔗vaults
🔗why-how-what
🔗season7-B
🔗postmarket
🔗postmarket-trail
🔗laptop
🔗trucko
🔗metrics
¶ →RFC (37)
🔗alike
🔗boating
🔗canarias
🔗coop
🔗ecology
🔗engineering
🔗events
🔗farming
🔗fuerteventura
🔗hacker-tools
🔗hacker-vans
🔗in-nature
🔗kranj
🔗lim0
🔗maps
🔗new-hackbase
🔗newcomers
🔗nomadbases-reboot
🔗paris
🔗project-hss
🔗representation.systems
🔗resources
🔗site-balea
🔗systematics
🔗tech-tree
🔗toxoplasmosis
🔗trucko-mobile
🔗theme-neo-css
🔗e2h-todo
🔗cht-official
🔗postmarket-for-toddlers
🔗hackbase-type1
🔗hackbase-type4
🔗workflow-bookmarklets
🔗graph-postapple
🔗graph-postapple-wtf
🔗laptop-buy
🔗alike
🔗boating
🔗canarias
🔗coop
🔗ecology
🔗engineering
🔗events
🔗farming
🔗fuerteventura
🔗hacker-tools
🔗hacker-vans
🔗in-nature
🔗kranj
🔗lim0
🔗maps
🔗new-hackbase
🔗newcomers
🔗nomadbases-reboot
🔗paris
🔗project-hss
🔗representation.systems
🔗resources
🔗site-balea
🔗systematics
🔗tech-tree
🔗toxoplasmosis
🔗trucko-mobile
🔗theme-neo-css
🔗e2h-todo
🔗cht-official
🔗postmarket-for-toddlers
🔗hackbase-type1
🔗hackbase-type4
🔗workflow-bookmarklets
🔗graph-postapple
🔗graph-postapple-wtf
🔗laptop-buy
¶A) QUICK
Send feedback to info@totalism.org , in the Telegram 🔗channel, or anywhere in 🔗contact.
Tell me:
* I took ### minutes to go through it
* I scanned it, it generally looks fine OR needs more work
* Found some typos: ###
* It feels cringe at this part: ###
* I get the point, but not this part: ##
* The single weakest part feels ###, strongest ###
* I learned something new / nothing new for me / ###
### editor@totalism.org [!]
Send feedback to info@totalism.org , in the Telegram 🔗channel, or anywhere in 🔗contact.
Tell me:
* I took ### minutes to go through it
* I scanned it, it generally looks fine OR needs more work
* Found some typos: ###
* It feels cringe at this part: ###
* I get the point, but not this part: ##
* The single weakest part feels ###, strongest ###
* I learned something new / nothing new for me / ###
¶ * While reading, note down
the typos
any cringe/awkward parts
unclear or duplicate parts
strong parts
general suggestions
the typos
any cringe/awkward parts
unclear or duplicate parts
strong parts
general suggestions
¶ * Give some general feedback
Consider ...
* How much time did you take reading the page?
* Is the specific page ready to release?
* What was the favorite part of the page?
* What was the least clear of the page?
* Give some general thought about the pad
go through page and classify accordingly !!!
[!→] @@padwork ... develop this classification
###
* Do you feel like the pad is:
A) convince you to do something specific?
### did it work? where not? #polemics
B) trying to systematize, inform about a topic
### was it valuable
C) schematize a generally useful protocol?
### informing for CHT, but you're not going so it's a curiosity? or general?
D) organize CHT-specific details?
### did it appear clear?
E) ???
* Did you understand everything?
* ... any words you needed to google/wikipedia?:
(did you appreciate that?)
* Did you learn something new about the project from this page?
* What did this page remind you of?
* Do you have something content to add?
* Would you like to keep working on it?
* Do your best to try explainining what CHT is, and how this page relates to it?
* Do you think this has value, or is important?
* ... should it be supported?
* Was it worth reading?
<----------------------------------------- (new) READER QUESTIONS ↑
Consider ...
* How much time did you take reading the page?
* Is the specific page ready to release?
* What was the favorite part of the page?
* What was the least clear of the page?
* Do you feel like the pad is:
A) convince you to do something specific?
B) trying to systematize, inform about a topic
C) schematize a generally useful protocol?
D) organize CHT-specific details?
E) ???
* Did you understand everything?
* ... any words you needed to google/wikipedia?:
(did you appreciate that?)
* Did you learn something new about the project from this page?
* What did this page remind you of?
* Do you have something content to add?
* Would you like to keep working on it?
¶ C1) MARK ON DOCUMENT
EASY: marking on the document
Used for DRAFTs.
* Open the page in two tabs:
1) Read mode
2) Edit mode:
(accessed by "Edit site" button on read mode)
You can also set this up easily with 🔗workflow-bookmarklets !
* In edit mode, use marks:
### or ###xx (where "xx" is your initials), and comments
(example: "###dp this is unclear")
Used for DRAFTs.
* Open the page in two tabs:
1) Read mode
2) Edit mode:
(accessed by "Edit site" button on read mode)
You can also set this up easily with 🔗workflow-bookmarklets !
* In edit mode, use marks:
### or ###xx (where "xx" is your initials), and comments
(example: "###dp this is unclear")
¶ C2) WITH HYPOTHES.IS TOOL
Used for RFCs, typically content-related proposals.
Instructions:
on setting up the tool, and
on accessing pages in annotation mode:
→ 🔗hypothesis.
[!!→] @@symbols
Mark, using hypothes.is:
(+) what you found lucid & important
(?) what you didn't understand
(?) or want expanded
(-) what you thought should be rewritten
(-) or made shorter
Used for RFCs, typically content-related proposals.
Instructions:
on setting up the tool, and
on accessing pages in annotation mode:
→ 🔗hypothesis.